University of Missouri Extension

WQ320, New May 1994

Sizing Dairy Soil/Plant Filters With Conservative Management

Charles D. Fulhage and Donald L. Pfost
Department of Agricultural Engineering

Approval permits

The Missouri Department of Natural Resources (DNR) requires a permit or letter of approval for constructing and/or operating dairy enterprises above a certain size (Table 1).

Table 1
Size of dairy operation requiring a letter of approval

Type of animal Construction/operation permit or letter of approval
Mature lactating dairy cows 150 or more
Dry cows and heifers 500 or more

Present regulations are primarily concerned with concentrated animal feeding operations. A concentrated animal feeding operation is defined as an operating location where animals have been, are or will be stabled or confined and fed or maintained for 45 days or more in any 12-month period, and a groundcover of vegetation is not sustained on at least 50 percent of the animal confinement area.

If dry cows and heifers are kept in a concentrated location with the milking cows, the total concentrated animal units will determine the requirements for a letter of approval or permit.

Operations smaller than listed in Table 1 may not be required to obtain a letter of approval but are required to operate in a no-discharge manner in compliance with the Missouri Clean Water Law.

Approval of an animal waste management system by DNR requires that sufficient land be available to receive the generated waste. If you do not own suitable land, a legally binding agreement must be reached with neighboring landowners to allow spreading the waste on their land. A specific form (M121-F, Spreading Agreement) is available from DNR outlining the necessary requirements.

DNR currently accepts three approaches for estimating land-area requirements for the soil/plant filter receiving the spread wastes. They are conservative management, intensive management and plant-available nitrogen approaches.

These approaches differ in the degree of detail required for estimating land-area requirements. In general, the conservative management approach results in the greatest land-area requirement and the plant-available nitrogen approach requires the least land area.

The conservative management approach

This publication deals only with the conservative waste management approach to estimating land-area requirements for dairy waste.

The conservative approach to sizing the soil/plant filter for animal waste disposal is based on the annual application of 100 pounds of nitrogen per acre with no allowance for application loss. This approach is intended as a conservative application rate that is suitable for all soils and crops.

This method is used in Missouri when land area available for waste disposal is not limited. By contrast, the intensive approach is used when the land area available for waste disposal is limited. The intensive (nutrient removal) approach to sizing the soil/plant filter more closely matches manure nutrient application to crop nutrient needs. In some situations, the operator may choose to base waste application limits on phosphorous or potassium, because of excessive amounts of phosphorus or potassium in the soil, rather than on nitrogen removal. However, the Missouri DNR currently uses nitrogen rather than phosphorous and potassium to size the minimum soil/plant filter area.

In estimating the land-area requirements under the conservative management approach, the adjusted thousand-weights of animals is multiplied by an index figure for the type of operation. The result is the acres of soil/plant filter area required for a permit under this approach. Table 2 gives the index figures for dairy cattle.

Table 2
Index figures for estimating the land area needed under the conservative management approach

Animal type Index figure per 1,000 of animal live weight1
For lagoon effluent For liquid/solid manure
Dairy 0.1432 0.8333
1Index figures based on applying 100 pounds nitrogen per acre per year. Does not include losses during land application (Manual 121, Table 7). The thousand-pound units should be adjusted downward for percent of time animals are on pasture, etc., since their manure will not be directed to the concentrated feeding facility.
2Assumes 100 percent of annual manure production to soil/plant filter via a lagoon.
3Assumes 100 percent of annual manure production to soil/plant filter as liquid or solid.

How to determine land-area requirements

The following example, along with Worksheets 1 and 2, illustrates how to determine land-area requirements using the conservative management approach.

Estimate the land-area requirement using the conservative management approach for a dairy with 150 cows averaging 1,400 pounds per cow in a combination confined feeding/pasture situation, such that 80 percent of the total manure production will occur in confinement and 20 percent will be dropped on pasture. Compare the land-area requirement for the manure from the confinement facilities if handled as a liquid with the land-area required if the manure is treated in a lagoon.

For the example under the conservative management approach using liquid manure, 140 acres of soil/plant filter must be available for land application versus only 24 acres required if manure is treated in a lagoon. This procedure is primarily intended to ensure that sufficient land is available to receive waste from a given size dairy operation. Spreading the manure on the noted acreage for the given size operation will not necessarily meet the nutrient needs of the crop. For example, nitrogen losses following land application and before incorporation may be substantial. In some cases, the phosphorus and potassium applied using this approach may exceed the requirements of the crop.

Table 3 gives land-area requirements for different size dairy operations, assuming the cows average 1,400 pounds each and 100 percent of the manure is removed from a concentrated or confined dairy.

Table 3
Soil/plant filter land area required by DNR for approval of operations under conservative management. Numbers are rounded up to the next whole number

Number of cows Acres required
For lagoon effluent For liquid/solid manure
100 20 117
200 40 234
300 60 350

Nutrient utilization and management

To have value, wastes must be utilized in a manner that results in a salable product. To keep the addition of nutrients from waste and fertilizer in balance with the nutrient removal by crops requires a record-keeping system. Use laboratory tests showing the nutrient content of the wastes that were applied. The quantities of waste added and crops removed should be measured or estimated as accurately as possible. Reliable nutrient data requires that the waste be kept well mixed during the loading, sampling, transport and land application process.

Percent loading worksheet

Form M121-G in Manual 121 contains a procedure for determining the percent loading to a lagoon or basin, to pasture, or hauled for various manure handling scenarios. MU Extension agricultural engineering specialists and Natural Resources Conservation Service engineers have a computer program that performs the calculations for this table.

Worksheet 1

Estimating land-area requirements for liquid manure:
  Example Your farm
1. Calculate thousand-weights of animals:
150 cows x 1,400 pounds per cow ÷ 1,000 pounds = 210 ______
2. Adjust the thousand-pound units for time on pasture:
Adjustment factor = 1.0 - 0.2 = 0.8
210 x 0.8 = 168 ______
3. Multiply the adjusted animal weight from (2) by the index number from Table 2.
168 x 0.833 = 140 acres ______

Worksheet 2

Estimating the land-area for lagoon effluent:
  Example Your farm
1. Calculate thousand-weights of animals:
150 cows x 1,400 pounds per cow ÷ 1,000 pounds = 210 ______
2. Adjust the thousand-pound units for time on pasture:
Adjustment factor = 1.0 - 0.2 = 0.8
210 x 0.8 = 168 ______
3. Multiply the adjusted animal weight from line 2 by the index number from Table 2.
168 x 0.143 = 24 acres ______


WQ320, new May 1994

WQ320 Sizing Dairy Soil/Plant Filter With Conservative Management | University of Missouri Extension

Order publications online at or call toll-free 800-292-0969.

University of Missouri Extension - print indicia