New March 2005

Link to  free PDF of this documentDownload a free PDF of this guide.


Order printed copies

Contents

Related pages

Use our feedback form for questions or comments about IPM1026.

Publication search

All words Any word

Ladybird beetle

Ladybird beetles, known for their appetite for aphids, occur naturally in Missouri but also can be introduced as biocontrol agents in greenhouses and nurseries.

Using Integrated Pest Management in Greenhouses and Herbaceous Nurseries

James Quinn
Research Associate
David Trinklein
State Floricultural Extension Specialist
Division of Plant Sciences

The U.S. Department of Agriculture has promoted integrated pest management (IPM) for more than 30 years. Most greenhouse and nursery producers are now aware of and use some IPM practices, which include a broad range of cultural, physical, biological, chemical, and mechanical tactics. IPM stresses routine inspection and monitoring and recommends pesticide use only when a potential problem is detected, or can be predicted to occur with a great deal of certainty. When pesticide use is determined necessary, IPM favors use of products that are least toxic to the environment, and will favor beneficial insects. Some newer products also use or introduce beneficial fungi and bacteria. This guide is designed to help growers who wish to select pesticides that have these attributes and to practice IPM.

Biologically based, novel and reduced-risk pesticides

Use of pesticides has changed dramatically in the last 30 years. Both users and manufacturers rely less on carbamates, organophosphates and chlorinated hydrocarbons. Reduced use of these chemical classes was compensated for by synthetic pyrethroids, but since about 1985 the Environmental Protection Agency has encouraged development of many novel, reduced-risk and "bio" pesticides. These pesticides are preferred for IPM in greenhouses and herbaceous nurseries when they exhibit one or more of the following characteristics: nonpersistence, minimal toxicity to beneficial organisms (they are as specific to the pest as possible) and high activity (smaller quantities of active ingredient are used).

The term novel insecticide refers to several classes of agricultural insecticides with unique modes of action that were registered in the late 1990s and early 2000s and have low mammalian toxicity. The active ingredient imidacloprid (Marathon 1 percent G, II, & 60 percent WSP) has been used successfully in the ornamental market and is an example of a novel insecticide. It is from a class of nicotine-based products referred to as "neonicotinoid or chloronicotinyl."

In 1993 EPA defined reduced-risk pesticides as compounds that pose a lower health risk to humans and the environment. The ensuing initiative included incentives for development and registration. The term reduced risk may not appear on the label but is often mentioned in promotional material. Many novel insecticides are considered reduced-risk, especially if they have been recently developed. An example is acetamiprid (TriStar), a reduced-risk "second generation" neonicotinoid. A successful product for ornamentals has been pymetrozine (Endeavor), which is in the class pyridine or amino triazinones. Numerous insect growth regulators (IGRs) have been introduced as reduced-risk, such as bifenazate, diflubenzuron and pyriproxyfen (Floramite, Adept and Distance). Check the technical information before using an IGR; the effectiveness on the adult stage of pests varies.

Biopesticides are based on biological organisms. Some are also considered novel insecticides. Examples include spinosad (Conserve), abamectin (Avid), and the products based on Bacillus thuringiensis (Dipel and Gnatrol). Biofungicides, or microbial fungicides, that have gained a niche include Trichoderma harzianum (Rootshield/Plantshield) and Bacillus subtilis (Companion and Subtilex). Fungicides are much less likely than insecticides to harm beneficial insects; only microbial fungicides are included in Table 1. The "natural products" are generally short-lived in the environment. This characteristic has provided some botanical extracts with broad labeling for use (all fruits and vegetables) and for short intervals between application and harvest. Examples include Azatin (from neem seed), and Pyreth-it (pyrethrum from chrysanthemum flowers). All "synthetic" pyrethroids are essentially based on pyrethrum.

New products are generally more quickly registered for ornamentals because they are nonedible and do not require extensive food safety testing. Unfortunately registration for greenhouse vegetable crops is usually delayed or may never occur. This can lead to confusion, especially with regard to vegetable bedding plants. Table 1 lists reduced-risk and novel pesticides labeled for ornamentals and vegetables. It is always a good idea to check product labels to make sure that the pest and site match an intended use.

Other insect and disease control materials that complement IPM practices

Reducing pesticide use

Best practices for reducing the use of pesticides in greenhouses and nurseries include the following:

Beneficial insects in Missouri

The greenhouse environment does not favor the number and diversity of beneficial insects typically found in an outdoor setting. This is because a greenhouse provides a less diverse habitat, a physical barrier, and (typically) a more heavily managed environment. Survival of beneficial insects in this environment is greatly influenced by the number and availability of pests they feed upon. The principal pests in Missouri's greenhouse and herbaceous nurseries are aphids, thrips, fungus gnats, mites, caterpillars, white flies, mealybugs and shore flies.

Aphidius wasp The aphid's body, which mummifies

The Aphidius wasp, left, stings the aphid and lays an egg in the aphid's body, which mummifies, right, as the egg develops.

Marion Herbert, Alberta Research Station, Vegreville, photo

Certain predators and parasites occur naturally in the greenhouse:

The following table shows additional predators and parasites that may occur naturally in the nursery:

Beneficial insect

Use of beneficial predators and parasites has been spurred by greenhouse vegetable production. "Biocontrol" generally works better when plants are cultivated over an extended period and when temperature or environmental conditions are constant. Preventive release of beneficial insects works better and is easier in a single crop system where one or two pests can be reliably predicted to occur. The importance of reducing pesticide use increases when bumblebees are used as pollinators. Tolerable infestation levels are higher with vegetable production because vegetables such as tomatoes and cucumbers are saleable even if the plant has a pest problem. Suppliers of beneficial predators and parasites are one of the best sources of technical information about their use.


The following table lists several beneficial predators and parasites that can be obtained commercially.

Beneficial insect

Management considerations for using beneficial insects Whenever beneficial insect predators and parasites are introduced, a primary concern is to avoid harming them with pesticides that may need to be applied for other reasons. This concern is partly alleviated by the wide range of "beneficial friendly" insecticides available.


Some tips and thoughts on developing an IPM plan using beneficial predators and parasites include:

What’s a current label?

Only the label that is on or included with the pesticide container at the time of purchase is considered current. Even if the manufacturer has expanded the use of an insecticide, labeling regulations require that you purchase new product with the expanded use label.

It is important that the distributor is able to correctly inform you about the label on the product, especially if there have been recent changes.

Printing an expanded or revised label from a manufacturer’s Web site and putting it with the product does NOT comply with the regulations.

For more information

Missouri Department of Agriculture Bureau of Pesticide Control
P.O. Box 630
Jefferson City, MO 65102
573-751-5511

Summary

Most IPM practices tend to be best management practices and are frequently in use. The increased number of reduced-risk pesticide products in recent years provides the opportunity to make the environment friendlier to beneficial insects. Introducing beneficial predators and parasites can add another level of complexity to IPM, but it is the most user-friendly form of pest control. Most growers will gain by learning to recognize beneficial insects and altering their pest control when practical to favor them.

Table 1
Pesticides labeled for ornamentals and greenhouse vegetables.
(Selected novel, reduced-risk, biologically based products)

Trade name (active ingredient)

Adept (diflubenzuron)

Admire 2F (imidacloprid)

Akari 5SC (fenpyroximate)

Avid (avermectin)

Azatin -- 3 percent a.i. (azadiractin)

Other azadiractin labels include Aza-Direct (1.2 percent), Neemix (4.5 percent) and Ornazin (3 percent)

Botaniguard (Beauvaria bassiana)

Other labels include Mycotrol and Naturalis

Citation (cyromazine)

Confirm (tebefenozide)

Conserve (spinosad or Saccharopolyspora spinosa)

Diatect V (0.5 percent natural pyrethrins and 82.45 percent silicon dioxide)

Dipel DF (Bt var. kurstaki)

Distance (pyriproxyfen)

Endeavor (pymetrozine)

Enstar (kinoprene)

Flagship (thiamethoxam)

Floramite (bifenazate)

Gnatrol (Bacillus thuringiensis Strain H-14)

Hot Pepper Wax (capsaicin)

Marathon (imidacloprid)

Formulations include, II (foliar), 1 percent granular, and 60 WP (drench)

Ovation (clofentezine)

Pedestal (novaluron)

Preclude TR (fenoxycarb)

Pyganic EC 5.0 (5.0 percent natural pyrethins)

Pyrellin E.C. (0.6 percent natural pyrethrins, 0.5 percent rotenone, 0.5 percent resins)

Pyreth-It (6.0 percent natural pyrethrins and 60.0 percent piperonyl butoxide)

Pyrethrum TR (4.0 percent natural pyrethins and 16.0 percent piperonyl butoxide)

Talus (buprofezin)

Tetrasan (etoxazole)

Tristar (acetamiprid)

Triac 70 (clarified hydrophobic extract of neem oil)

Microbial fungicides

Agri-mycin 17 (Streptomycin sulfate)

AQ-10 (Amperomyces quisqualis)

Bio-Trek 22G (Trichoderma harzianum)

Companion (Bacillus subtilis)

Mycostop (Streptomyces bacterium)

Plantshield (Trichoderma harzianum)

Rhapsody (AS) and Serenade (WP) (Bacillus subtilis)

Rootshield (Trichoderma harzianum)

SoilGard 12G (Gliocladium virens)

Sonata (Bacillus pumilus)

Subtilex (Bacillius subtilis)

Notes
Always read and follow label directions when using any of these products. Trade names are used to simplify the information, but active ingredients are provided. Inclusion of product names in this guide should not be regarded as an endorsement. Efficacy against pests is not addressed. Growers need to use and become familiar with the products in their operation and make decisions regarding effectiveness based on their application method, pests and crops.

Detailed information on safety for beneficial insects

Table 2
Greenhouse pesticides restricted to homeowner/hobbyist use. Not for commercial use.
(Selected novel, reduced-risk, biologically based products)

Trade name (active ingredient)

Bon-Neem Insecticidal Soap-Bonidev

i-Bomb (0.05 percent natural pyrethins and 0.5 percent piperonyl butoxide)

Rotenone-pyrethrin-Bonide (0.8 percent natural pyrethins, 1.1 percent rotenone and 2.2 percent cube extractives)

Whitmire 1600 (0.3 percent natural pyrethins and 2.2 percent piperonyl butoxide)

Fungicides

Serenade-Garden; ready to use.

Detailed information on safety for beneficial insects

More information

IPM publications

Selected biocontrol suppliers

Insect identification

Pesticides

Electronic newsletters

The authors acknowledge support from the Pesticide Environmental Stewardship Program of the Environmental Protection Agency, Region 7.

IPM1026, new March 2005